On Monday, 20 December, gig workers with Urban Company, a domestic services platform in India, began protesting against new policies instituted by the platform. According to the workers, the new policies will have a far-reaching impact on the flexibility of their work schedules. When workers protested in October against high platform commissions and other work conditions, Urban Company reduced its commission and took steps to improve certain work conditions. But in response to the recent protests, Urban Company has sued the alleged protest leaders in a petition filed in the Gurgaon District Court on Wednesday 22 December.
The recent policy changes introduce a new subscription system for beauticians (called ‘salon partners’ by Urban Company) that will categorize them as ‘Prime’, ‘Classic’ or ‘Flexi’: Under this new system, workers will be required to pay an upfront fee of 2000 (Classic) to 3000 Rupees (Prime) to be guaranteed jobs. Workers will also be required to perform a specific number of jobs per week. Workers who fail to complete the required number of jobs will be categorized as ‘Flexi’, a category that will not permit them to take on any jobs through the platform between Monday and Friday.
In addition to the new subscription system, Urban Company has introduced a new discount system for customers: Customers will be eligible for a discount of up to 10%, which will be deducted from workers’ wages.
Professor Balaji Parthasarathy, Principal Investigator, Fairwork India, argues that the recent workers’ protests and the reaction of the platform point to a couple of issues about gig work:
“First, there is a contradiction with Urban Company’s new subscription system, which compels workers to complete a minimum number of jobs while classifying these workers as ‘independent contractors’. The new subscription system significantly reduces workers’ flexibility, which is typically sold as a central advantage of gig work.
Second, the fact that Urban Company has petitioned against four alleged protest leaders in court is indicative of the company’s reluctance to recognize workers’ collectives and to negotiate with them. In its petition, the company recognizes that the number of protesters is ‘extremely large’, for which reason it was ‘not possible to sue each worker individually’. If anything, the large number of protesters shows that workers are articulating legitimate concerns that go beyond individual grievances. Hence, regardless of workers’ classification, consultation and negotiations with workers are a necessary step towards fair work.
As things stand, it should come as no surprise if the reluctance of financially and technologically powerful platforms to bridge the asymmetries between them and their socially vulnerable workers fuels more protests. Platforms may term their workers as ‘partners’, but it is an unequal partnership.”
Find out more about working conditions in the Indian gig economy in the Fairwork India reports and ratings.
Urban Company reached out to Fairwork with a response to the blog. The platform pointed out that workers under the ‘Smart’ and ‘Flexi’ plans are free to choose when they want to work and are allowed to work throughout the week. According to the platform, the customer discount is 4% and limited to those customers with a ‘Plus subscription’. They also stated that they had filed an injunction against their partners to vacate the company premises after a dialogue between the management and partners showed no progress.
Fairwork could not independently verify these details with workers. However, we will be tracking all aspects of the new subscription plans with workers and with Urban Company in 2022.
This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
This cookie remains on your computer for 365 days, but you can adjust your preferences at any time by clicking on the "Cookie settings" link in the website footer.
Please note that if you visit the Oxford University website, any cookies you accept there will appear on our site here too, this being a subdomain. To control them, you must change your cookie preferences on the main University website.
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.
This website uses the following additional cookies from third party websites:
These cookies will remain on your computer for 365 days, but you can edit your preferences at any time through the "Cookie Settings" in the website footer.
Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!
This website uses Google Tags and Google Analytics to collect anonymised information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages. Keeping these cookies enabled helps the OII improve our website.
Enabling this option will allow cookies from:
These cookies will remain on your website for 365 days, but you can edit your cookie preferences at any time via the "Cookie Settings" button in the website footer.